Standing Up For Justice And The Underdog

Does Car Insurance Go Up if Accident Not Your Fault?

On Behalf of | Oct 21, 2025 | Car Accidents |

Getting into an accident is stressful. You have to deal with the hospital bills and the damage to your car. But discovering later that your car insurance might still go up afterward can feel downright unfair. Many drivers just like you wonder how rates can rise when the crash was not even their fault. But the sad truth is, fault is not the only factor that insurance companies consider when reassessing your premiums.

Why do rates go up even after a not-at-fault accident?

In Iowa, premium increases depend on several factors, and it may not always have something to do with who was responsible for the crash. The insurance company’s internal policy could simply have increased or maybe there was an issue with the type of claim filed. Insurers also consider the risk data tied to the driver’s record.

If the insurers pay the claim under collision or comprehensive coverage, even without fault, they might still view it as a sign of higher risk, especially if you have filed several claims in the same year. Regardless of blame, the insurance company may increase the premium because you are considered “accident-prone.” It is an unfair assumption, but insurers usually base it on prior data.

What drivers should do after a not-at-fault crash

Even if you are not at fault, there are still steps you need to take to prevent complications later. Some of these include the following:

  • Report the crash accurately: Leave nothing out. Give your insurer a highly detailed account of everything that happened and make sure you provide documentation.
  • Verify the police report: Make sure the report correctly identifies who caused the accident, because insurers will use the information found on these records.
  • Ask about forgiveness programs: Some insurers offer “claims forgiveness” or “accident forgiveness” that protects drivers from rate hikes after certain incidents.

You cannot really undo an accident, but you can still protect yourself from its aftereffects.

How to manage rates moving forward

There really is no other way to avoid surprises except to ask your insurer directly how your recent claim might affect future premiums. Only then can you decide whether you should look for another insurance company with lower rates or renegotiate certain clauses in your current policy.

When to contact a car accident lawyer

If your insurer denies your claim or you believe you are being unfairly blamed for an accident, a car accident lawyer can help protect your rights. An attorney can review your case, gather evidence and negotiate with insurance companies to ensure you receive the compensation you deserve. A well-practiced lawyer on your side can make the difference between a stressful claims process and a fair outcome.

Archives

RSS Feed